Antique Stores on Long Island, NY: Complete Guide to Vintage Shopping (2026)

Long Island has earned a well-deserved reputation as one of the premier destinations for antique shopping in the New York metropolitan area. Thanks to the region's rich history dating back to colonial times, antique stores on Long Island, New York offer an exceptional variety of treasures ranging from fine European furniture and rare coins to vintage toys and mid-century modern décor. Whether you're a seasoned collector searching for period pieces or a casual shopper looking to add character to your home, this comprehensive guide will help you navigate the best antique shopping destinations across Long Island.

Why Long Island Is a Premier Destination for Antique Shopping

Long Island's unique position as a historic region with deep ties to American heritage makes it an ideal hunting ground for antiques. The area's wealthy estates, maritime history, and proximity to New York City have resulted in a concentration of high-quality antiques flowing through local shops for generations.

Long Island is quite the trove for treasures, including antique furniture, fine China and porcelain, and even vintage toys from all around the world. The diversity of available items reflects centuries of trade, immigration, and cultural exchange that have shaped the region.

From the bustling antique districts in Long Island City to the charming barn shops scattered along the North Fork's Route 25, antique enthusiasts will find stores catering to every taste, budget, and collecting interest. Many establishments feature professional appraisers on staff, offering free initial evaluations that can help both buyers and sellers understand the true value of pieces.

Top Antique Stores in Long Island City

Long Island City, located in Queens just across the East River from Manhattan, has emerged as a significant hub for antique dealers and collectors. The neighborhood's warehouse spaces provide ideal settings for displaying large collections of period furniture and decorative arts.

John Koch Antiques

John Koch Antiques stands out as one of the premier destinations in Long Island City, operating from a spacious 5,000-square-foot warehouse filled with vintage and antique treasures. The establishment brings 35 years of experience as estate buyers to their diverse collection. Collectors can explore multiple floors featuring Victorian furniture, antique prints, carved wood easels, and an impressive selection of decorative items including cookie jars, mirrors, and period artwork.

Address: 47-22 37th Street, Long Island City, NY 11101 Phone: (718) 937-1758 Website: kochantiques.com Hours:

Monday–Friday: 11 AM–5 PM
Saturday: By appointment

Allstate Antiques Inc

Allstate Antiques Inc offers a diverse selection that includes vintage toys, exquisite jewelry, rare coins, antique ceramics, paintings, and unique collectibles. The store is known for its knowledgeable staff who can provide insights into the history behind each item.

Address: 39-06 Crescent Street, Long Island City, NY 11101 Phone: (718) 472-2241 Hours:

Monday–Friday: 11 AM–4 PM

Charles Cheriff Galleries

Charles Cheriff Galleries presents an impressive collection of antique furniture, rare coins, and fine jewelry. The gallery offers personalized service with expert advice from experienced staff.

Address: 22-19 41st Ave, Suite 202, Long Island City, NY 11101 Phone: (212) 675-6131 Website: charlescheriffgalleries.com Hours:

Monday–Friday: 9 AM–5 PM

Miguel Saco Fine Furniture Conservation and Restoration

For those with treasured antique furniture in need of expert care, Miguel Saco Fine Furniture Conservation and Restoration specializes in restoring and conserving fine furniture. The workshop is renowned for meticulous attention to detail and offers consultation for custom restoration projects.

Address: 39-50 Crescent St, Suite D, Long Island City, NY 11101 Hours:

Monday–Friday: 8 AM–4:30 PM

Paul Stamati Gallery

Paul Stamati Gallery offers a diverse selection of antiques and collectibles, including vintage furniture, rare coins, and paintings. The gallery is known for its welcoming atmosphere and knowledgeable staff.

Address: 51-2 21st Street, Long Island City, NY 11101 Website: stamati.com Hours:

Monday–Friday: 11 AM–5 PM

Specialty and Weekend Shops

Several Long Island City establishments cater to specific collecting interests or weekend shoppers:

Sparr's Militaria & Antiques at 4115 Broadway specializes in military memorabilia and historical artifacts, including rare coins, vintage items, and unique collectibles. Open Tuesday through Friday from 12 PM to 6 PM.

Just Things at 47-28 Vernon Blvd operates exclusively on weekends (Saturday and Sunday, 12 PM to 5 PM), offering vintage furniture, rare coins, collectible toys, antique ceramics, and retro textiles in a welcoming browsing environment.

Underpenny at 10-13A 50th Ave opens Thursday through Sunday with varying hours, featuring vintage furniture, rare coins, and unique collectibles.

Lampem's Gallery at 47-61 Pearson Pl offers vintage furniture, rare coins, and exquisite jewelry, operating Monday through Thursday from 11 AM to 3:30 PM.

Exploring Long Island's North Fork Antique Trail

The North Fork of Long Island offers a distinctly different antique shopping experience. The area features bucolic fields, vineyards, and stunning beaches alongside a wonderful assortment of vintage and antique stores, home goods, stationery, food shops, and farm stands.

Route 25: The Antique Corridor

Many of Long Island's North Fork antique destinations are located along Route 25, making it convenient to combine antique hunting with visits to beaches, farm stands, and wineries. You can search for hidden gems in barns and rummage shops along this scenic route.

Beall & Bell

Located in Greenport at 430 Main Street, Beall & Bell occupies a former Memorial Masonic Temple built in 1901. The establishment houses an extensive collection of American, French, and English mid-century furniture, antiques, and industrial items within its high-ceilinged warehouse setting. Co-founders Virginia McFadden and Kenneth Ludacer have been curating and selling unique antique furniture, accessories, and décor items since 1992. The inventory changes frequently, so regular visits are recommended.

Address: 430 Main Street, Greenport, NY 11944 Phone: (631) 477-8239

Small Holdings Farm

This 3,000-square-foot barn in Aquebogue at 965 Main Road specializes in vintage garden finds. Small Holdings Farm is filled with one-of-a-kind vintage garden treasures including vintage oars, antique signage, and wrought iron pieces.

Address: 965 Main Road, Aquebogue, NY 11931

The Times Vintage

At 429 Main Street in Greenport, The Times Vintage offers a retro-kitsch experience with vintage clothing, vinyl records, and an impressive mid-century glass and lamp collection. There's a lot of nostalgia for visitors who recognize wallpaper patterns or phones from their childhood kitchens.

Address: 429 Main Street, Greenport, NY 11944 Phone: (631) 477-6455

Lydia's Antique & Stained Glass

Lydia's Antique & Stained Glass at 215 Main Street in Greenport has become a North Fork antiquing landmark, carrying a wide selection of antiques and tableware, including much sought-after Blue Willow china. The owner also makes and repairs stained glass.

Address: 215 Main Street, Greenport, NY 11944 Phone: (631) 477-1414

Award-Winning Antique Destinations Across Long Island

Several Long Island antique stores have earned recognition for exceptional quality and service.

Rosie's Vintage

Located at 187 Park Avenue in Huntington, Rosie's Vintage has been voted Best Long Island Antique Store multiple years running. The multi-vendor store creates fresh themed displays monthly, with dealers collaborating to showcase their vintage treasures. The store also hosts regular antique markets throughout the year and maintains an online marketplace.

Address: 187 Park Avenue, Huntington, NY 11743 Phone: (631) 549-9100 Website: rosiesvintagestore.com Hours:

Daily: 11 AM–6 PM

Remember Yesteryears

This Oakdale establishment at 901 Montauk Highway in the Lighthouse Commons Shopping Center features collections from approximately 120 dealers under one roof. Remember Yesteryears offers everything from furniture and jewelry to military paraphernalia and is known for its knowledgeable and helpful staff.

Address: 901 Montauk Highway, Oakdale, NY 11769 Phone: (631) 654-3052 Website: rememberyesteryears.com

Deep End of the Sandbox

Located in Oceanside, Deep End of the Sandbox has been recognized as one of the best antique stores on Long Island. The inventory ranges from video games to furniture and home décor, appealing to nostalgia seekers and collectors alike. The store specializes in rare and hard-to-find vintage pieces from the 1950s through the 1990s.

Address: Oceanside, NY

The Vintage Living

Also in Oceanside along Long Beach Road, The Vintage Living has developed a loyal following. Owner Raphael is knowledgeable and offers fair prices, while the store maintains a continuous flow of new merchandise.

Address: 2863 Long Beach Road, Oceanside, NY 11572

Other Notable Long Island Antique Destinations

Stam Gallery

Formerly known as Giles Antiques, Stam Gallery at 287 Main Street in Port Washington is the place for buying or selling fine art and antiques. Owner Steven Stam is an experienced appraiser and specializes in period antiques (pre-1840s).

Address: 287 Main Street, Port Washington, NY 11050 Phone: (516) 883-1104 Hours:

Daily: 12 PM–5:30 PM

Garden City Antiques and Fine Arts

This upscale antique and thrift store at 730 Franklin Avenue in Garden City specializes in entire estate liquidations and has experienced staff who can assist with appraisals.

Address: 730 Franklin Avenue, Garden City, NY 11530 Phone: (516) 873-8200 Hours:

Monday–Friday: 8:30 AM–6 PM

Antique Attics

Located in Lake Grove at 2789 Middle Court, Antique Attics is a treasure trove of antiques, vintage items, and collectibles. From furniture and home décor to toys and memorabilia, this store offers a vast selection. They also offer on-site consultations and consignment opportunities.

Address: 2789 Middle Court, Lake Grove, NY 11755

Back in Time Vintage Home Décor

Located in Farmingdale Village, Back in Time is a hidden gem offering an impressive array of unique, high-quality items. From antiques to home décor, the store's vast selection caters to diverse tastes. The back of the shop features a cozy coffee shop and bakery, and customers can partake in classes ranging from furniture painting to floral arrangements.

Address: Farmingdale, NY

Essential Tips for Antique Shopping on Long Island

Know the Terminology

Antiquing has a language all its own. Understanding terms related to different time periods, manufacturers, and item conditions will help you shop more effectively and negotiate appropriately. An "antique" is typically 100 years or older, while "vintage" refers to items less than 100 years old.

Verify Authenticity

Look for identifiable markings and logos that prove authenticity. Search for prints underneath glasses, bowls, and dishes to verify the origin and age of items.

Seek Professional Appraisals

Many upscale antique shops have experienced professional appraisers on hand, and it is common for them to give an initial appraisal for free, helping both buyers and sellers understand fair market value.

Come Prepared

Practical preparation enhances the antique shopping experience:

Bring a tape measure to ensure items will fit in your space and vehicle
Carry cash as some dealers prefer it and may offer better prices
Research prices online before shopping to understand fair market values
Consider repair costs for items needing restoration, as rewiring and upholstery can be expensive

Plan for Transportation

Large furniture pieces require appropriate transportation. Measure doorways and consider delivery options before purchasing substantial items.

Frequently Asked Questions About Antique Stores on Long Island, New York

How many antique stores are on Long Island?

Long Island hosts dozens of antique stores spread across Nassau and Suffolk counties, with concentrations in Long Island City, Huntington, Greenport, Oakdale, and along the North Fork's Route 25. Many locations feature multiple dealers under one roof, significantly expanding the available inventory.

What types of antiques can I find on Long Island?

Long Island antique stores offer diverse collections including period furniture (pre-1840s through mid-century modern), fine jewelry, sterling silver, rare coins, vintage toys, military memorabilia, antique clocks, porcelain and ceramics, paintings and prints, vintage clothing, and architectural salvage.

Are antique stores on Long Island open on weekends?

Hours vary by location. Many Long Island City stores operate primarily on weekdays, while North Fork shops and multi-dealer centers often maintain weekend hours. Some establishments like Just Things operate exclusively on weekends. It's advisable to call ahead or check websites before visiting.

Do Long Island antique stores offer appraisal services?

Yes, many upscale antique shops have professional appraisers on staff. Initial appraisals are commonly offered free of charge at established stores.

What is the best time to visit antique stores on Long Island?

Weekday mornings often offer quieter browsing experiences, while weekends may have more selection as some shops only open Saturday and Sunday. The North Fork is particularly pleasant during spring and fall when you can combine antique shopping with visits to wineries and farm stands.

Can I negotiate prices at Long Island antique stores?

Negotiation is generally acceptable at antique stores, though practices vary by establishment. Cash payments may facilitate better deals. Looking for needed repairs or imperfections can provide legitimate reasons to discuss price adjustments.

Planning Your Long Island Antique Shopping Trip

For the most rewarding experience, consider organizing your antique shopping expedition by region:

Long Island City: Ideal for serious collectors seeking quality furniture and decorative arts. Plan a weekday visit and allow several hours to explore the warehouse-style shops.

North Fork: Combine antique hunting with wine tasting and farm visits. Route 25 offers multiple stops that can fill an enjoyable day trip. Greenport alone features Beall & Bell, The Times Vintage, and Lydia's Antique & Stained Glass within walking distance.

South Shore: Visit multi-dealer centers like Remember Yesteryears in Oakdale for one-stop shopping across diverse categories.

North Shore: Explore Huntington-area shops including Rosie's Vintage for curated vintage finds.

Long Island's antique stores offer something for every collector and casual shopper. Whether you're seeking a statement piece for your home, adding to a specific collection, or simply enjoying the thrill of discovery, the region's rich selection of antique destinations awaits your exploration.

Last updated: March 2026